I just read a post on my f-list about this topic and it's prompted me to post my own thoughts on this, because this is something that's been bothering me for a while now.
I'll be the very first to admit it: at first, I thought the whole crew being on twitter was awesome. I loved the fact that they were willing to open themselves up to the fans, answer questions, give us insight into how they work, snippets of deleted scenes or bloopers. I
still love those things because it fascinates me and I love the show, and I appreciate that some PTBs are willing to share all of that. I especially appreciate it, that they remain sharing this stuff, because they get god knows how many idiot fangirls pestering them every day with ridiculous questions/requests/demands/etc. If they ever chose to private their twitters for that very reason, I wouldn't blame them.
But while I still appreciate their generosity, I'm no longer comfortable with the fact that the 'fourth wall' is no longer there. Not only has it made fandom so much worse of a place to be in, fuelling fan entitlement, fuelling further hate and division, you name it, I also feel like my enjoyment of what I do in fandom has been restricted. Like, before I didn't have to
worry about potential exposure to TPTB. But now I
do worry about it. I worry that ANY person who contributes work to the
House fandom might end up getting unwanted exposure to TPTB. Twitter has made the division between fandom and TPTB paper thin; they're just a tweet away from being linked to someone's fanvid or fanfic or fanart. Maybe that's melodramatic of me but tbh, the way people (not all, but quite a few) carry on with GY et al. on twitter, I can't put it past them that they'd start linking to fanart and fanvids and fanfics etc, thinking that GY etc would love it as much as fandom folk do. For all I know, they probably have already sent GY et al. links to fandom works. That's the thing that makes it so uncomfortable for me: the fact that now the fourth wall has been knocked down, there's no controlling who links who to what or who sees what.
Even them just posting links on their own twitter like, "OMG THIS IS AN AWESOME FANVID/FANFIC" - @yoteddy
friends/follows back every person who friends/follows him. What if he clicked on one of those links and then reported it to GY? Or to some other PTB, who has an issue with copyright? Shit could end up going down that affects not only the individual whom the fanwork belongs to, but to the whole fandom.
Yeah, I know it hasn't happened yet (that I know of). For all I know, maybe they sit back in their offices and lol their heads off at what people create. Maybe they read House/Cuddy porn out aloud to each other. Maybe they print out House/Wilson smut and pass it on to Hugh or RSL to read and gape in horror at. No one has any idea what goes on in their offices besides what they've been willing to share with us. But as the adage goes, there's a first time for everything. And while almost all people add disclaimers to their fanwork, that they don't own the characters or footage used, that doesn't make them exempt from being slapped with a copyright warning or worse. I know TPTB are very aware of their fanbase - I know they enjoy fanart and have even put some of it up in their office (GY posted a picture of the office 'bragging wall', and on said wall was a piece of fanart that was made by
green_ghost). Perhaps they're fully, completely aware of the stuff that's out there but we're a lucky enough fandom that they turn a blind eye to it. Who really knows. No one knows because TPTB have never shared their thoughts on this. But regardless, where does the line get drawn? Surely I'm not the only one who thinks/feels that fandom has a Big Brother element added to it now?
TPTB are NOT one of us, by any means. Just because they delight in House/Cuddy or House/Wilson or their love of the show that they're involved in creating, or they enjoy 'mingling' with the fans or enjoy fannish contributions etc, it doesn't mean they're the same as us. It makes me so fucking uncomfortable that so many people in this fandom
do not even consider this.
Edit:
anoel just reminded me of
Organisation for Transformative Works, which I always forget is there for the purpose of being a kind of protection for fandom folk. So, I guess this makes part of my rant now moot. ;-) But I still stand by the whole fourth wall being knocked down thing. I don't know if it irks you - awesome if it doesn't! - but it sure as hell irks me.
EDIT 2: OKAY, I'VE COME UP WITH AN ANALOGY THAT EXPLAINS HOW I FEEL ABOUT THIS IN THE MOST PERFECT WAY:
It's like looking up porn when your parents are in the house. If they're in another room, then looking it up is a lot easier because they're not around to see you doing it and you KNOW your chances of getting caught are low. But now I just feel a bit like I'm looking up porn on the internet with a parent lurking in the background in the same room and I keep looking over my shoulder to make sure I don't get caught.